Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement
A mutual insurance company with over 100 years of experience, known for personalized service, competitive rates, and strong financial stability in the Medicare Supplement market.
Mutual of Omaha
NAIC: 71412
Est. 1909
Financial Strength Ratings
A.M. Best
A+
Superior
Moody's
A1
Investment Grade
S&P Global
A
Strong
Customer Satisfaction
4.1/5
Industry Rating
Pros & Cons Analysis
Strengths
Excellent financial stability and ratings
Competitive pricing in many markets
Strong customer service reputation
Flexible underwriting guidelines
Long-standing Medicare expertise
Mutual company structure benefits policyholders
Considerations
Smaller market presence than top carriers
Limited digital tools compared to larger insurers
Fewer rating classes than some competitors
Not available in New York
Available Medicare Supplement Plans
Special Features & Benefits
Personal service approach with local agents
Stable premium history
Simplified underwriting process
Health and wellness resources
Loyalty rewards for long-term policyholders
What Customers Say
Positive Feedback
Excellent customer service and personal attention
Stable premiums over time
Easy claims process
Trusted brand with long history
Areas for Improvement
Limited online tools and digital features
Smaller network may limit provider choices
Less competitive in some urban markets
Financial Stability Overview
Total Assets
$8+ billion
Surplus Ratio
Excellent
Risk-Based Capital
400%+
Trend
Stable
Ready to Compare Mutual of Omaha Rates?
Get instant quotes from Mutual of Omaha and other top carriers in your area. Compare plans, benefits, and pricing to find your perfect Medicare Supplement coverage.